The Recall Desk
HighFDA (Food)·H-0071-2026·Announced 2025-10-15

Toto S'Mores Cookie recalled for conflicting soy ingredient labeling

Toto Foods recalls S'Mores Ooey Gooey Cookies due to conflicting label statements regarding soy content. The package contains contradictory information about whether the product includes or is free from soy.

What this means for you

Real risk of harm even if no illness or injury has been reported yet. Stop using the product and follow the agency's guidance.

Our severity reasoning: This FDA Class II recall involves allergen mislabeling on a common allergen (soy). The conflicting label statements create a potential hazard for consumers with soy allergies. No illnesses have been reported; the hazard is preventive. Score per allergen mislabeling without reported illness criterion.

Plain-English summary

Toto Foods, Inc. is recalling Toto S'Mores Ooey Gooey Cookies (2.25 OZ, UPC 860010409398) due to conflicting label statements about soy content. The product label contains contradictory information regarding whether the cookie includes or is free from soy.

This labeling error creates a potential hazard for consumers with soy allergies who depend on accurate product labeling for safety. The recalled product (120,180 units total) was distributed to retailers in Maryland, California, Arizona, New Jersey, Georgia, Connecticut, Ohio, Indiana, Texas, Illinois, Pennsylvania, New York, Florida, and Colorado. Affected units carry best-by dates from January 15, 2026 through April 27, 2026.

Consumers who purchased this product should verify their package and discard it if they have a soy allergy and cannot confirm the actual soy content. For more information, contact Toto Foods, Inc.

The recalled product

Product
Toto S'Mores Ooey Gooey Cookie; Gluten Free & Dairy Free; Net Wt. 2.25 OZ Rear panel: Packed with superfoods; Gluten, Dairy & Soy Free UPC: 860010409398
Manufacturer
Toto Foods, Inc.
Category
Food — Cookies
Hazard
  • allergen-soy
  • mis-labeling

Is your product affected?

Check your packaging against the codes below. If any of them match, the product is part of this recall.

Lot numbers (1)

  • BB 01.15.26 - 04.27.26

Distribution

Distribution scope not specified by the agency.

Related recalls

Same category