Gardner Pie Company Recalls Key Lime Pies Due to Peanut Contamination
Gardner Pie Company is recalling 163 key lime pies sold in Ohio because the graham cracker crumbs used in the crust may contain peanut residue.
What this means for you
Real risk of harm even if no illness or injury has been reported yet. Stop using the product and follow the agency's guidance.
Our severity reasoning: The recall involves allergen mislabeling/contamination (peanut) on a common allergen. The source text does not report any illnesses or injuries, fitting the 'High' severity criteria for allergen issues without reported harm.
Plain-English summary
Gardner Pie Company is recalling 163 individual 32-ounce key lime pies. These pies were sold exclusively at the firm's retail outlet in the state of Ohio. The pies are packed in a cardboard carton with an aluminum pie pan and a plastic dome lid. The retail pies are not labeled, and customers are provided the flavor of the pie they select for purchase.
The recall was initiated after the firm was notified by their supplier that the graham cracker crumbs used to make the bottom crust of the pies were potentially contaminated with peanut residue. The flour used to manufacture the crumbs is the source of the potential contamination. The same crumbs are also used in the production of cheesecake, but this recall specifically addresses the key lime pies.
Consumers who purchased these pies should check their home for the product. Since the pies are not labeled, consumers should verify the purchase date and location if they are unsure. The source text does not specify a date range or lot numbers, as there are no codes on the pies.
The recalled product
- Product
- Product is a 32-ounce Key Lime pie sold at the firm's retail outlet only. Pie is packed in a cardboard carton with an aluminum pie pan and a plastic dome lid. Retail pie is not labeled. Customers are provided the flavor of pie they select for purchase.
- Manufacturer
- Gardner Pie Company
- Category
- Food — Baked Goods / Pies
- Hazard
- Affected units
- 163
Is your product affected?
Check your packaging against the codes below. If any of them match, the product is part of this recall.
Lot numbers (1)
- No codes on pies.
Distribution
Distributed in 1 state:
Part of a larger recall action
This product is one of 2 recalled by Gardner Pie Company under a single FDA (Food) recall action. The agency files each product separately, so the size of the action is not visible from this page alone.
See all 2 products in this recall →Related recalls
Same manufacturer · Gardner Pie Company
See all →- HighGardner Pie Company Recalls Cheesecakes Due to Peanut Contamination
FDA (Food) · 2016-09-21
Same hazard · allergen peanut
See all →- SevereKHONG GUAN Recalls Rice Balls Due to Undeclared Peanuts
FDA (Food) · 2026-09-02
- CriticalFDA Recalls Glutinous Rice Balls with Undeclared Peanuts
FDA (Food) · 2026-09-02
- CriticalBazzini Dark Chocolate Coconut Almond Bites Recalled for Undeclared Peanuts
FDA (Food) · 2026-08-19
- HighOLA-OLA Pounded Groundnuts recalled for undeclared peanuts
FDA (Food) · 2026-07-22
- HighHigh Valley Orchard Chocolate Covered Raisins Recalled for Undeclared Peanut
FDA (Food) · 2026-07-15