Stevens Bakery Recalls Toll House Pies for Undeclared Milk
Stevens Family Bakery & Orchard LLC is recalling Toll House Pies because the label failed to declare milk ingredients found in butter.
The agency’s classification
FDA (Food): Class II
Class II is a situation in which use of or exposure to a violative product may cause temporary or medically reversible adverse health consequences, or where the probability of serious adverse health consequences is remote.
This is the agency’s own classification, taken from its notice. The severity score below is our assessment, not the agency’s. How recall classes work
What this means for you
Our assessment, not the agency’s: severity 3/5 (High).
Real risk of harm even if no illness or injury has been reported yet. Stop using the product and follow the agency's guidance.
Our severity reasoning: The recall involves allergen mislabeling on a common allergen (milk), which corresponds to a severity score of 3 per the rubric.
Plain-English summary
Stevens Family Bakery & Orchard LLC is recalling 16 Toll House Pies, including baked whole, half, and frozen varieties. The recall is due to a labeling error where the ingredient statement failed to include the components of butter, which contain undeclared milk.
The affected products were distributed only in Ohio. Baked whole pies have a 'BEST USED BY' date of November 8, 2017, while frozen pies do not have a 'BEST USED BY' date.
Consumers with these products should stop using them and contact the manufacturer for further instructions.
The recalled product
- Product
- Toll House Pie Baked whole/half pies & frozen pies, Stevens Bakery & Orchard ,7344 Thackery Road, Springfield, Ohio 45502, (937) 788-2873
- Manufacturer
- Stevens Family Bakery & Orchard LLC
- Category
- Food — Baked Goods
- Affected units
- 16
Is your product affected?
Check your packaging against the codes below. If any of them match, the product is part of this recall.
Lot numbers (1)
- Baked whole pies = BEST USED BY NOV 08 2017 & Frozen pies = No BEST USED BY date
Distribution
Distributed in 1 state:
Part of a larger recall action
This product is one of 13 recalled by Stevens Family Bakery & Orchard LLC under a single FDA (Food) recall action. The agency files each product separately, so the size of the action is not visible from this page alone.
See all 13 products in this recall →Related recalls
Same manufacturer · Stevens Family Bakery & Orchard LLC
See all →- HighStevens Bakery Sugar Cream Pies Recalled for Undeclared Milk Allergen
FDA (Food) · 2018-02-14
- HighStevens Bakery Peach Pies Recalled for Undeclared Milk Allergen
FDA (Food) · 2018-02-14
- HighStevens Bakery Recalls Lemon Pies Due to Undeclared Wheat and Milk
FDA (Food) · 2018-02-14
- HighStevens Bakery Recalls Apple Streusel Pies for Undeclared Milk
FDA (Food) · 2018-02-14
- ModerateStevens Bakery Recalls No Sugar Added Pumpkin Pies for Missing Aspartame Warning
FDA (Food) · 2018-02-14
Same hazard · allergen milk
See all →- HighFrozen Cheese Pie Recalled for Undeclared Milk Allergen
FDA (Food) · 2026-10-14
- SevereBetter Bakehouse Recalls Donutful Chocolate Dipped Vanilla Cake Donuts for Undeclared Milk
FDA (Food) · 2026-10-14
- HighFannie May S'mores Collection Recalled for Undeclared Milk and Pecans
FDA (Food) · 2026-09-16
- HighPrince Bakery Recalls Pan De Manteca for Undeclared Milk Allergen
FDA (Food) · 2026-09-09
- SevereSavor Seasonings Recalls Organic Cheddar Seasoning for Undeclared Milk Allergen
FDA (Food) · 2026-09-09
Similar recalls
- HighBridge City Baking Recalls Gluten-Free Cherry Crumble Pies for Undeclared Milk
FDA (Food) · 2015-05-27
- HighBridge City Baking Recalls Gluten-Free Apple Crumble Pies for Undeclared Milk
FDA (Food) · 2015-05-27
- SeverePleasant House Bakery Recalls Steak and Chicken Pies for Undeclared Allergens
USDA FSIS · 2015-08-14
- HighUrban Oven Cookies Recalled for Undeclared Milk Allergen
FDA (Food) · 2016-03-16
- ModerateRobeson Enterprises Recalls Strawberry Pie for Missing Sub-Ingredient Labeling
FDA (Food) · 2024-04-17
- HighBell Stone Toffee Recalls Toffee Chocolate Bars Due to Milk Allergen Labeling Error
FDA (Food) · 2017-03-08