The Recall Desk
HighFDA (Food)·F-0699-2025·Announced 2025-04-16

Lillie's Q Buffalo Wing Sauce recalled for undeclared milk allergen

OLD WORLD SPICES & SEASONING, INC is recalling Lillie's Q Buffalo Wing Sauce (13.5 oz bottles, Lot #002125 and others) because milk, present as a sub-ingredient in butter, is not declared on the label or in the "Contains" statement.

What this means for you

Real risk of harm even if no illness or injury has been reported yet. Stop using the product and follow the agency's guidance.

Our severity reasoning: This recall involves a common allergen (milk) that is mislabeled on the product label. Allergen mislabeling on common allergens meets the High severity criterion, even though no illnesses have been reported, because the undeclared allergen poses a direct risk of harm to allergic consumers.

Plain-English summary

OLD WORLD SPICES & SEASONING, INC is recalling Lillie's Q Buffalo Wing Sauce (13.5 oz bottles, UPC 810069510972, Lot #002125 with best-by date JAN/21/2026, as well as Lot #002025 and Lot #005725) due to an undeclared milk allergen. Milk is present in the product as a sub-ingredient of butter but is not listed in the ingredient statement or in the "Contains" statement on the label.

Approximately 8,532 bottles have been distributed to distribution centers in Kansas, Florida, New Hampshire, California, Iowa, Georgia, Texas, Colorado, Connecticut, Wisconsin, New York, Washington, and Pennsylvania. Consumers who have a milk allergy or sensitivity and have purchased this product should not consume it. Anyone with questions or who believes they may have been affected should contact their healthcare provider.

The recalled product

Product
Lillie's Q Buffalo Wing Sauce. Net wt. 13.5 oz, UPC 810069510972, Case label: Lillie's Q Buffalo Wing Sauce, Item # FGLOL422 Lot # 002125, 6/13.5 oz, UPC 10810069510979, BEST BY: JAN/21/2026
Manufacturer
OLD WORLD SPICES & SEASONING, INC
Category
Food — Condiments / Sauces
Hazard
  • allergen-milk
  • mis-labeling

Is your product affected?

Check your packaging against the codes below. If any of them match, the product is part of this recall.

Lot numbers (4)

  • Lot #002125
  • BEST BY: JAN/21/2026 Lot #002025
  • BEST BY: JAN/20/2026 Lot #005725
  • BEST BY: FEB/25/2026

Distribution

Distributed in 13 states:

  • CA
  • CO
  • CT
  • FL
  • GA
  • IA
  • KS
  • NH
  • NY
  • PA
  • TX
  • WA
  • WI

Related recalls

Same category