Sunny Side Farms Ice Cream Recalled for Flavor Mismatch
Super Store Industries is recalling Sunny Side Farms Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream because some containers are filled with Butter Pecan ice cream.
The agency’s classification
FDA (Food): Class II
Class II is a situation in which use of or exposure to a violative product may cause temporary or medically reversible adverse health consequences, or where the probability of serious adverse health consequences is remote.
This is the agency’s own classification, taken from its notice. The severity score below is our assessment, not the agency’s. How recall classes work
What this means for you
Our assessment, not the agency’s: severity 2/5 (Moderate).
Minor labeling or packaging issue, or a voluntary precautionary recall. Risk of harm is low but real — follow the manufacturer's instructions.
Our severity reasoning: The recall is classified as FDA Class II, which typically involves a low probability of serious adverse health consequences. The hazard is a flavor mismatch and potential allergen exposure (peanuts/pecans) rather than a high-risk pathogen or structural defect.
Plain-English summary
Super Store Industries-Turlock Dairy Division is recalling 8,580 cartons of Sunny Side Farms Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream, 48 oz. The recall is due to a packaging error where some containers labeled as Peanut Butter Cup flavor are actually filled with Butter Pecan ice cream and have Butter Pecan lids.
The affected product is distributed in California and Nevada. The lot number and best-by date for the recalled items is 07/14/2019. The Peanut Butter Cup flavor contains milk, peanuts, soy, and coconut, while the Butter Pecan flavor contains milk and pecans. Both products are manufactured in a facility that also processes peanuts, tree nuts, wheat, soy, and egg.
Consumers who have purchased this product should check the lot number and best-by date. If the product matches the recalled description, consumers should stop using it and contact the manufacturer for instructions on disposal or return.
The recalled product
- Product
- Sunny Side Farms Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream; 48 oz. carton, 1.5 QTS (1.42L) UPC: 7-17544-20740 5 Allergens for Peanut Butter Cup: Milk, Peanuts, Soy, Coconut. Allergens for Butter Pecan: Milk, Pecans Both packages include the following statement: While best…
- Manufacturer
- Super Store Industries-Turlock Dairy Division
- Category
- Food — Ice Cream
Is your product affected?
Check your packaging against the codes below. If any of them match, the product is part of this recall.
Lot numbers (1)
- LOT & BEST BY DATE: 07/14/2019
Distribution
Related recalls
Same manufacturer · Super Store Industries-Turlock Dairy Division
See all →- HighSunnyside Farms Peach Yogurt Recalled for Coconut Allergen Contamination
FDA (Food) · 2019-08-07
Same hazard · mis labeling
See all →- SevereWhite Vein Advanced Alkaloids Chewable Tablets Recall for Excess Active Ingredient
FDA (Food) · 2026-10-14
- ModerateHalyard Laparoscopy Comprehensive Pack II Recalled for Latex Content
FDA (Devices) · 2026-10-14
- HighFreshPoint Recalls Cranberry Chicken Salad Wedges for Undeclared Egg Allergen
FDA (Food) · 2026-10-14
- HighJ K Patisserie & Bakery LLC Recalls Croissants for Undeclared Egg
FDA (Food) · 2026-10-14
- HighJ K Patisserie Chocolate Chip Cookies Recalled for Undeclared Soy
FDA (Food) · 2026-10-14
Similar recalls
- HighSassy Cow Creamery Recalls Ice Cream Due to Undeclared Pecan Allergen
FDA (Food) · 2019-06-12
- HighSunnyside Farms Peach Yogurt Recalled for Coconut Allergen Contamination
FDA (Food) · 2019-08-07
- SevereButter pecan ice cream recalled for undeclared allergens and color additives
FDA (Food) · 2023-11-22
- SevereSouthwest Ice Cream Specialties Recalls Ice Cream for Undeclared Allergens
FDA (Food) · 2013-06-19
- HighMercer's Ice Cream Recalled for Undeclared Soy Allergen
FDA (Food) · 2012-12-05
- HighEaton Farm Peanut Butter Bar Recalled for Soy Allergen Mislabeling
FDA (Food) · 2016-01-27