Smith Dairy Peanut Butter Brownie Crunch Ice Cream Recalled for Sunland Peanut Butter
Smith Dairy Products is recalling 3-gallon tubs of Peanut Butter Brownie Crunch ice cream because the peanut butter used was supplied by Sunland, Inc.
The agency’s classification
FDA (Food): Class I
Class I is a situation in which there is a reasonable probability that the use of or exposure to a violative product will cause serious adverse health consequences or death.
This is the agency’s own classification, taken from its notice. The severity score below is our assessment, not the agency’s. How recall classes work
What this means for you
Our assessment, not the agency’s: severity 5/5 (Critical).
Highest-severity recall. The hazard can cause serious injury or death. Stop using the product now and follow the agency's instructions.
Our severity reasoning: The source metadata explicitly identifies this as an FDA Class I recall, which corresponds to a Critical severity score of 5 according to the rubric.
Plain-English summary
Smith Dairy Products Company is recalling 2,211 three-gallon tubs of SD Peanut Butter Brownie Crunch ice cream. The recall was initiated after the company was notified by its supplier, Pecan Deluxe, that the peanut butter crunch candies used in the ice cream were made with peanut butter supplied by Sunland, Inc.
The affected product was shipped to Indiana, Michigan, Ohio, and West Virginia. The product is identified by UPC 70424 08639 and lot numbers 197-10, 201-11, 129-11, 159-11, 103-12, and 159-12.
Consumers should check their inventory for the specific lot numbers and UPC listed above. If they have the affected product, they should contact Smith Dairy Products Company at 1-800-778-7078 for instructions on disposal or return.
The recalled product
- Product
- SD Peanut Butter Brownie Crunch 3 Gallon MFD. BY SMITH DAIRY PRODUCTS COMPANY, ORRVILLE, OHIO 44667 1-800-778-7078.
- Manufacturer
- Smith Dairy Products Co
- Category
- Food — Ice Cream
- Hazard
Is your product affected?
Check your packaging against the codes below. If any of them match, the product is part of this recall.
Lot numbers (6)
- UPC 70424 08639
- Lot #'s: 197-10
- 201-11
- 129-11
- 159-11 103-12
- 159-12
Distribution
Part of a larger recall action
This product is one of 2 recalled by Smith Dairy Products Co under a single FDA (Food) recall action. The agency files each product separately, so the size of the action is not visible from this page alone.
See all 2 products in this recall →Related recalls
Same manufacturer · Smith Dairy Products Co
See all →- CriticalSmith Dairy Peanut Butter Ice Cream Recalled for Peanut Butter Source
FDA (Food) · 2012-11-07
- SevereSmith's Lemon Iced Tea Recalled for Undeclared Milk Residue
FDA (Food) · 2012-09-05
Other food recalls
- SevereKayem Foods Recalls Ready-to-Eat Meat and Poultry Due to Temperature Abuse
USDA FSIS · 2026-10-17
- Severe
- CriticalTodd's Seeds Sprouting Seed Mix Recalled for E. coli and Salmonella Risk
FDA (Food) · 2026-10-07
- CriticalTodd's Seeds Alfalfa and Mung Bundle Recalled for E. coli and Salmonella Risk
FDA (Food) · 2026-10-07
- SevereSalata Salad Kitchen Jalapeño Avocado Dressing Recalled for Salmonella Risk
FDA (Food) · 2026-10-07
Similar recalls
- CriticalPecan Deluxe Peanut Butter Crunch Recalled for Salmonella Risk
FDA (Food) · 2013-06-05
- CriticalSunland Natural Crunchy Peanut Butter Recalled for Salmonella Contamination Risk
FDA (Food) · 2012-10-31
- CriticalSunland Organic Crunchy Peanut Butter Recalled for Salmonella Contamination
FDA (Food) · 2012-10-31
- CriticalSunland Recalls Organic Crunchy Peanut Butter Due to Salmonella Risk
FDA (Food) · 2012-10-31
- SevereSweet Me Creamery Brookie Dough Ice Cream Recalled for Undeclared Peanuts
FDA (Food) · 2018-10-24
- CriticalSunland Organic Crunchy Peanut Butter Recalled for Salmonella Risk
FDA (Food) · 2012-10-31